First Coffee Join Free

Evangelical
First Coffee
in New York City

Your matchmaker

We find the
right person for you

No profile browsing. No swiping. Our team reviews your preferences and finds someone genuinely compatible from the Evangelical community in New York City.

Find your match
92% match
87% match

No more texting purgatory

Straight to
a real coffee date

Every match is a date. We pick the cafe, set the time, and all you have to do is show up.

Find your match
SAT
15
Blue Bottle Coffee
2:00 PM

Save the reveal for the cafe

Save the spark
for the cafe

Upload a selfie and get an illustrated avatar in 20 seconds. You'll recognize each other — but the real spark happens in person, not on a screen.

Find your match
Before
Photo
After
Avatar
Before
Photo
After
Avatar

Simple pricing

Pay per date.
No subscription.

First Coffee

$ 39

per date

  • Curated match from your community
  • Café selected for you
  • Full refund if unmatched
Get started

This Saturday
could be different.

One person. One café. One real conversation.

Get Started